|
TRANSLATE THIS ARTICLE
Integral World: Exploring Theories of Everything
An independent forum for a critical discussion of the integral philosophy of Ken Wilber
![]() Frank Visser, graduated as a psychologist of culture and religion, founded IntegralWorld in 1997. He worked as production manager for various publishing houses and as service manager for various internet companies and lives in Amsterdam. Books: Ken Wilber: Thought as Passion (SUNY, 2003), and The Corona Conspiracy: Combatting Disinformation about the Coronavirus (Kindle, 2020).
Check out my other conversations with ChatGPT
Geography and Geopolitics:
The Revenge of Geography: When Maps Become Destiny The Revenge of Geopolitical Realism What If Russia Invaded Ukraine for Security Reasons? Jared Diamond: The Geography of Human History The Revenge of Geopolitical RealismWhen Explaining Great-Power Behavior Becomes Excusing ItFrank Visser / ChatGPT
![]() Introduction: The Dangerous Comfort of Geopolitical NecessityThere is an important distinction between explaining why a country behaves in a particular way and justifying that behavior. In international relations, however, this distinction is frequently blurred, particularly when powerful states are involved. The war against Ukraine has brought this problem into sharp focus. Since Russia's full-scale invasion in February 2022, a considerable body of commentary has sought to explain Moscow's actions through the language of geopolitics: NATO expansion, Western encirclement, Russian historical insecurity, the strategic importance of Ukraine, and the supposed inevitability of great-power competition. Some of these considerations deserve serious examination. Russia has legitimate security interests, just as other countries do. NATO's post-Cold War policies can be debated, and Western foreign policy has certainly not been free of mistakes, inconsistencies, or military interventions that violated international law. But something happens when geopolitical explanation becomes a comprehensive justification. The agency of the aggressor begins to disappear. The victim's sovereignty becomes negotiable. Political decisions are transformed into structural necessities. And the responsibility for war gradually shifts from the government that launched it to the international environment in which it claims to have felt threatened. This is the revenge of geopolitical realism: a perspective originally intended to understand the limitations of international politics can become an intellectual device for excusing the behavior of powerful states. The problem is not realism itself. It is realism elevated into an all-encompassing worldview. 1. John Mearsheimer and the Tragedy of Great-Power PoliticsNo contemporary academic has become more closely associated with this interpretation of the Ukraine conflict than American political scientist John J. Mearsheimer. In his influential 2014 lecture, Why the Ukraine Crisis Is the West's Fault, Mearsheimer argued that Western efforts to bring Ukraine into the European orbit, particularly through NATO enlargement, provoked a predictable Russian response. His argument rests on structural realism. In an international system without a central authority capable of guaranteeing security, great powers must remain attentive to their strategic environment. They are especially sensitive to potentially hostile military alliances approaching their borders. From this perspective, Russia's reaction to the possibility of Ukrainian NATO membership was not surprising. Mearsheimer argued that Washington should have understood that Moscow would resist such a development. There is a serious argument here. Great powers do pay attention to military alliances, strategic depth, and the distribution of power. Western policymakers should not have assumed that Russia would welcome every development in its neighborhood. But Mearsheimer's interpretation has a significant weakness: it risks turning a theory about the behavior of great powers into a theory that excuses their behavior. If Russia was structurally compelled to invade Ukraine because of NATO enlargement, where does Russian political agency enter the picture? Why should the preferences of Moscow carry more weight than those of Kyiv? And why should a neighboring country be denied the right to determine its own security arrangements simply because a larger state dislikes its choices? The theory may explain why Moscow objected to Western influence in Ukraine. It does not establish that Russia had the right to dictate Ukraine's future. Nor does it demonstrate that invasion was inevitable. 2. The Security Dilemma: A Useful Concept with Dangerous ApplicationsOne of the most frequently invoked concepts in realist international relations is the security dilemma. A state takes measures to improve its security. Its neighbors interpret these measures as potentially threatening and respond with their own military preparations. The original state then sees these responses as confirmation of its insecurity. A spiral of mutual suspicion develops, even when neither side initially intended war. This is a valuable analytical framework. It helps explain why NATO enlargement could generate Russian anxieties, why Eastern European countries seek Western protection, and why military deployments can produce unintended escalation. But the security dilemma is not a universal solvent that dissolves responsibility. The security concerns of different states are not automatically equivalent. Nor are all military measures defensive in character. States can exaggerate threats, manufacture insecurity, pursue territorial ambitions, and deliberately use the language of self-defense to justify aggression. In the case of Ukraine, there is an especially important complication: NATO enlargement was not simply an expansion imposed on unwilling Eastern European populations. Countries such as Poland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, and eventually Finland and Sweden actively sought membership because of their historical experiences and perceptions of Russian power. Their decisions cannot be understood solely as Western geopolitical manipulation. The security dilemma works in both directions. Russian leaders may have perceived NATO as a threat, but Russia's behavior also encouraged its neighbors to seek NATO protection. A theory that recognizes only the insecurity of great powers while overlooking the insecurity of smaller states is not a balanced application of realism. It is a hierarchy of security interests disguised as geopolitical analysis. 3. Ukraine Is Not a Geographical BufferOne of the most persistent problems in geopolitical commentary is the tendency to discuss Ukraine as though it were an empty space between Russia and the West. In this perspective, Ukraine is a buffer zone, a strategic corridor, a geopolitical prize, or a contested sphere of influence. These descriptions may have analytical value, but they leave out something fundamental: Ukraine is a country inhabited by people who have political preferences, historical memories, institutions, and national aspirations. The right of Ukrainians to determine their political future is not a minor consideration to be weighed against the strategic convenience of Moscow and Washington. It is a central principle of international relations. The Helsinki Final Act of 1975, the United Nations Charter, and subsequent European security commitments all recognize principles of sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the right of states to choose their own political and security arrangements. Russia itself reaffirmed Ukraine's territorial integrity in the 1994 Budapest Memorandum, in exchange for Ukraine's accession to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty and its relinquishment of the nuclear weapons inherited from the Soviet Union. The geopolitical realist may respond that international law cannot override the realities of power. That is partly true. International law does not possess an independent military force capable of compelling every state to obey it. But this observation does not make international law irrelevant. It merely identifies one of the problems that international institutions must address. More importantly, the realist argument often contains an implicit double standard. Russia's security preferences are treated as hard geopolitical realities, whereas Ukraine's security preferences are treated as idealistic aspirations. Why should the geographical proximity of Russia give it a superior claim to determine Ukraine's future? A country does not lose its sovereignty because it happens to be located next to a more powerful neighbor. 4. NATO Expansion: Context Is Not ExculpationA serious discussion of the Ukraine war cannot simply dismiss the history of NATO enlargement. The alliance expanded eastward after the Cold War, incorporating countries that had previously belonged to the Warsaw Pact or Soviet sphere of influence. Western governments also discussed eventual NATO membership for Ukraine and Georgia, most notably at the 2008 Bucharest summit. These developments contributed to tensions with Moscow. There were also Western policy decisions that can reasonably be criticized. The invasion of Iraq in 2003, the intervention in Libya in 2011, and the inconsistent application of international legal principles damaged Western credibility. But none of this establishes that Russia was forced to invade Ukraine. The distinction between contributing to a hostile environment and causing a particular act of aggression is essential. Mearsheimer's argument is often presented as though NATO expansion were the decisive cause of the war. Yet Russia's relationship with Ukraine cannot be reduced to the question of NATO membership. Putin's own statements repeatedly reveal a much broader concern: the legitimacy of Ukrainian statehood and the historical relationship between Russians and Ukrainians. His July 2021 essay, On the Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians, and his February 2022 address preceding the full-scale invasion challenged the historical and political foundations of an independent Ukrainian nation. These statements deserve to be taken seriously as evidence of the Russian leadership's worldview. They suggest that the conflict was not simply about military infrastructure or the geographical position of NATO forces. It was also about the political independence of a neighboring country whose separate identity Putin has repeatedly questioned. A geopolitical explanation that overlooks this ideological and imperial dimension is incomplete. 5. Putin's Agency: The Missing VariableOne of the most striking features of deterministic geopolitical analysis is how easily political leaders disappear from the explanation. Russia becomes a geographical entity responding to strategic pressures. The Kremlin becomes an almost automatic mechanism for reproducing the country's historical security requirements. But Russia is not a machine. It is governed by human beings who make decisions, interpret threats, construct narratives, pursue political objectives, and sometimes make catastrophic mistakes. Putin had alternatives to invasion. Russia could have pursued negotiations, arms-control arrangements, confidence-building measures, or diplomatic agreements about military deployments. It could have accepted the development of a politically neutral but fully sovereign Ukraine. It could have concentrated on improving its economic attractiveness to its neighbors rather than attempting to control them through coercion. Whether these alternatives would have satisfied the Kremlin is another question. But their existence matters. The invasion was a political choice, not a geological event. Moreover, the Kremlin's decisions have repeatedly produced outcomes contrary to its stated strategic objectives. NATO has become larger, European military cooperation has intensified, Ukraine has become more hostile to Russia, and Moscow has become increasingly dependent on China. This is not the behavior of an actor mechanically following an unavoidable geographical script. It is the behavior of a political leadership making choices under constraints, with consequences that can be judged and evaluated. 6. The Asymmetry of Realist EmpathyA recurring feature of pro-Russian geopolitical commentary is an asymmetry of empathy. We are invited to understand Russia's historical trauma, its experience of invasion, its strategic insecurity, its loss of superpower status, and its fear of Western encroachment. All of these subjects are legitimate. But the same analytical generosity is not always extended to Russia's neighbors. Why did Poland seek NATO membership? Why did the Baltic states regard Russian military power as a threat? Why did Finland eventually abandon its long-standing military non-alignment? Why did Ukraine increasingly seek integration with Western institutions? These questions have equally intelligible historical and strategic answers. For many Eastern European countries, Soviet domination was not an abstract geopolitical arrangement. It was a lived historical experience involving occupation, repression, political subordination, and the denial of national independence. The fear of renewed Russian domination is therefore not necessarily Western propaganda. It has historical foundations. If Russian insecurity deserves to be understood in its historical context, so does Eastern European insecurity. Yet a particular version of realism often privileges the perspective of the strongest state in the region. The anxieties of smaller states become secondary considerations, while the preferences of the great power become the organizing principle of the analysis. This is not realism applied consistently. It is great-power centrism. 7. The Iraq Analogy and the Problem of Western HypocrisyAnother common argument in geopolitical discussions is that the West has no moral authority to criticize Russia because the United States has violated international law in the past. The invasion of Iraq in 2003 is frequently invoked, as is the NATO intervention in Libya in 2011. These comparisons are important. Western governments should not receive immunity from criticism simply because they claim to defend a rules-based international order. The Iraq War was based on profoundly misleading claims about weapons of mass destruction and involved a serious violation of the international legal framework. The aftermath was disastrous. The Libyan intervention also raises legitimate questions about the expansion of a civilian-protection mandate into regime change. But what follows from these precedents? Certainly not that Russia has acquired a license to invade neighboring countries. The proper conclusion is that international law should apply consistently, including to Western powers. If the United States violated international law in Iraq, it should be criticized. If Russia violates international law in Ukraine, it should be criticized as well. One violation does not cancel another. Nor does exposing Western hypocrisy automatically validate Russian conduct. This is an elementary distinction, yet it is frequently obscured by whataboutism: instead of examining the specific actions of the state under discussion, attention is redirected toward the wrongdoing of another state. The result is not a more consistent moral standard. It is the gradual abandonment of standards altogether. 8. The Difference Between Realism and CynicismRealism is often presented as a particularly hard-headed approach to international politics, in contrast to supposedly naïve idealism. But there is a difference between recognizing the role of power and assuming that power is the only meaningful political reality. A genuinely sophisticated realism should recognize that states pursue multiple interests. Security is important, but so are economic prosperity, political legitimacy, international reputation, domestic stability, and the benefits of cooperation. It should also recognize that international norms and institutions can influence behavior, even when they cannot guarantee compliance. The distinction between realism and cynicism is particularly important. Realism asks what is possible under existing conditions. Cynicism assumes that principles are merely rhetorical disguises for power. Realism recognizes that international politics involves conflicting interests. Cynicism concludes that the strongest actor is entitled to prevail. Realism takes security dilemmas seriously. Cynicism treats the security concerns of smaller countries as irrelevant whenever they conflict with those of a great power. There is nothing especially sophisticated about this last position. It simply reproduces the worldview of imperial politics. 9. The Paradox of Geopolitical Self-DefeatThe most serious weakness of the deterministic realist interpretation becomes apparent when we examine the actual consequences of Russia's invasion. If Moscow's principal objective was to prevent NATO expansion, the invasion has been spectacularly counterproductive. Finland joined NATO in April 2023, adding a substantial new border between Russia and the alliance. Sweden followed in March 2024. Ukraine has become more deeply integrated with Western military and political structures. European countries have increased defense spending and reconsidered their dependence on Russian energy. Russia has also suffered enormous human, economic, and diplomatic costs. These developments demonstrate an important limitation of geopolitical determinism: states do not merely respond to their geographical environment. They also transform it through their own actions. Russian policy helped create the very strategic environment that Moscow claimed to fear. This is a crucial point. The invasion was not simply a reaction to an external geopolitical reality. It became a major cause of the subsequent transformation of that reality. A theory that explains Russian aggression primarily as an unavoidable response to NATO expansion has difficulty accounting for this feedback loop. The security dilemma can become a self-fulfilling prophecy, but the state that contributes most directly to escalating the confrontation cannot escape responsibility by pointing to the existence of the dilemma. 10. Transcending the Realism-Idealism DivideThe debate between geopolitical realism and liberal internationalism is often presented as a choice between understanding power and defending principles. That is a false dichotomy. A mature approach to international relations needs both. Realism reminds us that good intentions do not eliminate strategic competition, that military capabilities matter, and that international institutions cannot simply wish away conflicts of interest. Liberal internationalism reminds us that states are not entitled to dominate their neighbors, that international cooperation is possible, and that sovereignty and international law provide essential protections against the arbitrary exercise of power. Neither perspective is sufficient on its own. A purely idealistic foreign policy can underestimate the dangers of military aggression and the limits of diplomatic goodwill. A purely realist foreign policy can normalize spheres of influence, sacrifice smaller countries, and mistake the preferences of great powers for universal geopolitical necessities. The challenge is to transcend this opposition without discarding the insights of either side. In the case of Ukraine, this means recognizing Russia's security concerns without granting Russia a veto over Ukrainian sovereignty. It means acknowledging Western mistakes without treating them as justification for Russian aggression. It means supporting negotiations without confusing peace with capitulation. And it means recognizing that a durable European security order cannot be built by simply accommodating the territorial ambitions of the strongest state. Conclusion: Understanding Power Without Surrendering JudgmentRobert Kaplan's The Revenge of Geography reminds us that international politics remains embedded in a physical world of borders, strategic corridors, waterways, and geographical vulnerabilities. John Mearsheimer's structural realism similarly reminds us that great powers are sensitive to the distribution of military capabilities and the strategic orientation of neighboring states. Both perspectives contain important insights. But neither geography nor structural realism should become an all-purpose explanation that dissolves political responsibility. Russia's geographical position helps explain its strategic concerns. Its historical experience helps explain its security culture. NATO enlargement helps explain some of its objections to Western policy. None of these factors establishes that the invasion of Ukraine was inevitable, necessary, or legitimate. The decisive distinction is between understanding why a state perceives something as threatening and accepting its claim to eliminate that perceived threat by force. A powerful country may feel insecure. It may resent the political choices of its neighbors. It may regard their independence as strategically inconvenient. But these feelings do not confer ownership over other nations. The ultimate danger of geopolitical realism is not that it takes power seriously. It is that, in some applications, it takes the interests of powerful states more seriously than the rights of everyone else. A genuinely mature geopolitics must resist that temptation. We should understand the geography of Russia without accepting the geography of a Russian empire. We should understand American power without excusing American violations of international law. We should understand the strategic interests of China without sacrificing the sovereignty of its neighbors. And above all, we should remember that countries are not merely spaces on a map. They are political communities. The final lesson is simple: explaining the behavior of great powers is an intellectual necessity. Excusing their aggression is a political choice. Comment Form is loading comments...
|

Frank Visser, graduated as a psychologist of culture and religion, founded IntegralWorld in 1997. He worked as production manager for various publishing houses and as service manager for various internet companies and lives in Amsterdam. Books: 