|
TRANSLATE THIS ARTICLE
Integral World: Exploring Theories of Everything
An independent forum for a critical discussion of the integral philosophy of Ken Wilber
![]() Frank Visser, graduated as a psychologist of culture and religion, founded IntegralWorld in 1997. He worked as production manager for various publishing houses and as service manager for various internet companies and lives in Amsterdam. Books: Ken Wilber: Thought as Passion (SUNY, 2003), and The Corona Conspiracy: Combatting Disinformation about the Coronavirus (Kindle, 2020).
Check out my other conversations with ChatGPT
The Mean Green Meme:
An allergy to Green goes a really long way Was Wilber prophetic about Woke Culture of just conservative? Ken Wilber's selective critique of the Mean Green Meme The Mean Green Meme Under Examination The Mean Green Meme Under ExaminationNatasha Todorovic's Challenge to Ken WilberFrank Visser / ChatGPT![]()
Introduction: Challenging an Integral OrthodoxyFew concepts in the history of Integral Theory have proved as rhetorically useful, and potentially as divisive, as Ken Wilber's Mean Green Meme (MGM). Introduced prominently in his 2002 book Boomeritis, the concept describes what Wilber considers a pathological expression of the Green developmental worldview. Green, originally associated with pluralism, egalitarianism, sensitivity, and inclusiveness, supposedly becomes distorted when its commitment to equality turns into an intolerance of hierarchy, an excessive suspicion of expertise, and an inability to recognize developmental differences. Wilber's diagnosis is provocative. The very worldview that prides itself on tolerance can become intolerant of anything that challenges its assumptions. Its rejection of hierarchy can become an absolute hierarchy of its own, with egalitarianism elevated into an unquestionable moral principle. There is something recognizable about this criticism. Contemporary political and cultural debates certainly provide examples of ideological conformity, moral policing, performative virtue, and the exclusion of dissenters in the name of inclusiveness. But does this justify identifying such behavior with a particular developmental stage? That is precisely the question Natasha Todorovic addresses in her 2002 paper, The Mean Green Hypothesis: Fact or Fiction? Her criticism deserves attention because she approaches the subject from within the Gravesian tradition on which Spiral Dynamics itself is based. Rather than simply defending Green against Wilber's criticism, she questions whether the proposed pathology can be demonstrated empirically at all. Her conclusion is uncompromising: the Mean Green Meme is a misdiagnosis that confuses different value systems, personality characteristics, and interpersonal conflicts. What Exactly Is Supposed to Be Mean About Green?Todorovic begins by examining the construction of the MGM concept. The expression belongs to a broader family of labels describing supposedly pathological versions of the Spiral Dynamics value systems. The basic idea is that each developmental worldview can exhibit unhealthy expressions that obstruct further development. In Wilber's formulation, Green has become particularly problematic because it supposedly combines Green pluralism with Red narcissism. In Boomeritis, he describes this combination as a Green worldview that has become diseased, disturbed, and frankly sick. The underlying argument is that Green's legitimate emphasis on equality and inclusion can become exaggerated into relativism, anti-hierarchical dogmatism, and hostility toward those who represent earlier or supposedly more advanced developmental perspectives. Todorovic questions whether this combination makes sense within Graves's original theory. She reminds readers that Graves described Green, or the FS system, as sociocentric and relationship-oriented. Its characteristic concerns include getting along, belonging, accepting the authority of the group, and finding satisfaction through participation and mutual acceptance. This description is important. Green is not necessarily an emancipated, radically individualistic worldview. Its concern for inclusion can itself become socially conformist. However, this does not automatically make Green aggressive, narcissistic, or predatory. Todorovic argues that Wilber has attributed characteristics to Green that cannot be established from Graves's research. The distinction between a developmental system and its possible pathological expressions is therefore crucial. If the latter are simply assumed rather than demonstrated, the theory risks becoming an exercise in labeling. The Empirical Challenge: Who Actually Rejects Green?The most interesting part of Todorovic's paper is its examination of data from more than 600 profiles collected using the National Values Center's Psychological Map, Form A, supplemented by sentence-completion tests. The instrument distinguishes between value systems that respondents identify with and those they reject. Todorovic calls these dimensions acceptance and rejection, or protrait and contrait patterns. Her central hypothesis is straightforward: if Green is genuinely perceived as particularly objectionable by people operating from more advanced developmental levels, then those levels should show unusually high rejection scores for Green. The results suggest something different. According to Chart 1 (page 3), the strongest Green rejection patterns are associated primarily with Blue, Orange, and the Blue/Orange combination. Of the respondents exhibiting elevated Green rejection, 46 percent belong to the Blue/Orange pairing, while 21 percent are associated with Orange and 17 percent with Blue. Together, these three categories account for 84 percent of the elevated Green rejection patterns. Yellow, meanwhile, accounts for only 7 percent. This is an important observation because one recurring interpretation of the Mean Green Meme is that it is primarily recognized by people who have moved beyond Green into more complex developmental perspectives. Todorovic's data do not support that interpretation. The strongest rejection of Green comes not from Yellow but from Blue and Orange. She also reports a negative correlation of .608 between Orange and Green acceptance, suggesting a substantial tendency for strong Orange identification to coincide with Green rejection. The implications are significant. Perhaps some of the people who diagnose Green as pathological are not speaking from a more encompassing developmental perspective at all. Perhaps they are expressing the values and preferences of the very systems that Green tends to challenge. This does not establish that every MGM critic is Orange or Blue. But it certainly complicates the claim that MGM criticism is a privileged expression of second-tier consciousness. The Yellow Problem: Is Second-Tier Thinking Being Misidentified?One of Todorovic's more interesting observations concerns what she calls the Yellow false positive. Her examination of sentence completions and individual profiles suggested that some respondents identified by the Psychological Map as Yellow were actually expressing more sophisticated forms of Orange thinking. In other words, the instrument sometimes appeared to mistake advanced achievement-oriented thinking for genuinely systemic and integrative thinking. This matters because developmental classifications are only as reliable as the instruments used to establish them. If people can be incorrectly classified as Yellow, then claims about the supposedly superior perspective of those diagnosing Mean Green become even more questionable. Todorovic suggests that some MGM advocates may be exhibiting precisely this combination: Blue's tendency to rank and classify, combined with Orange's achievement orientation and competitive individualism. There is an irony here. People who believe they have transcended conventional developmental thinking may still be operating within familiar competitive and hierarchical assumptions. However, there is also a methodological complication. Todorovic identifies false positives partly through sentence completions, direct observation, and her own knowledge of respondents. These are potentially useful supplementary methods, but they are not an independently established validation procedure. The paper itself acknowledges that the assessment instrument needs improvement. Her observation is therefore an important warning about developmental classification, rather than definitive proof that MGM advocates are predominantly Orange masquerading as Yellow. The Red-Green Combination: A Developmental Impossibility?Perhaps the most direct challenge to Wilber concerns his proposed combination of Red and Green. In the Mean Green Meme formulation, Green pluralism supposedly combines with Red narcissism to produce an aggressive, self-centered form of egalitarianism. Red supplies the power orientation, while Green provides the ideological justification. Todorovic argues that this combination is inconsistent with the developmental dynamics described by Graves. Drawing on more than 3,000 cases in her database, she reports finding no convincing evidence of Red and Green operating together as a dominant developmental combination. Instead, she finds that increasing Green identification tends to coincide with increasing rejection of Red. On page 7, she reports that 85 percent of the profiles dominated by Green reject Red more strongly than any other system. In the remaining 15 percent, Orange rejection is at least as strong. Her conclusion is that Green and Red do not naturally combine in the manner proposed by the MGM hypothesis. This is a substantial challenge, but it needs to be interpreted carefully. The absence of a characteristic developmental combination in an individual profile does not establish that people with different value orientations cannot cooperate politically or culturally. Nor does it establish that individuals cannot express contradictory tendencies in different situations. Todorovic recognizes this distinction herself when she considers whether MGM might describe a combination of individuals rather than a combination of value systems within one individual. Her subsequent analysis also finds little support for the idea that Green-centered respondents are unusually attracted to Red. In fact, she reports that Green acceptance is associated with strong Red rejection. The important point is that Wilber's proposed psychological combination requires more empirical justification than he provides. Who Is Actually Attacking Whom?Todorovic then turns to the assertion that Red and Green combine to attack Blue and Orange. Here she introduces a useful distinction between developmental value systems and the surface beliefs expressed by individuals. Two people may both endorse egalitarianism while operating from entirely different value systems. One may defend equality because it is an absolute moral principle, while another may approach it through pluralism and sensitivity to different perspectives. The surface belief is similar; the underlying motivation is not. This distinction is particularly relevant when interpreting political and cultural conflicts. A group defending equality is not necessarily Green, just as a group defending hierarchy is not necessarily Blue. Todorovic suggests that Wilber and other MGM proponents may sometimes mistake liberal Blue for a Green/Red combination. She also examines the possibility that conflict between Blue and Orange groups is being misinterpreted as Green and Red attacking them. Her discussion of Graves's observations about Blue-on-Blue conflict is particularly interesting. Graves described conflicts between different Blue-centered hierarchies as potentially among the most vicious and enduring forms of conflict. This complicates the assumption that authoritarian or hierarchical systems are inherently more peaceful than supposedly aggressive Green-oriented movements. The broader lesson is that political behavior cannot be reliably diagnosed from ideological content alone. We need to understand the underlying motivations, social circumstances, and interactions involved. The Personality Problem: Confusing Temperament with DevelopmentAnother important contribution of Todorovic's paper is her examination of personality characteristics. She asks whether the supposed meanness of Green might be expressed through rigidity, aggressiveness, Machiavellianism, or a lack of kindness. Drawing on Graves's research, she argues that these characteristics do not support the MGM hypothesis. Green is reportedly among the least rigid systems when compared with Blue and Orange. Orange scores particularly high on aggressiveness and Machiavellianism, while Green scores relatively low. Green also scores highly on kindness. These findings create an obvious difficulty for the idea that Green is inherently characterized by aggression and predatory behavior. Todorovic's argument here is conceptually important. A developmental value system should not be casually equated with a personality disorder, a temperament, or a particular interpersonal style. Someone can be aggressive while expressing very different worldviews. Likewise, someone can be kind while holding authoritarian beliefs. The problem is not that Green individuals cannot behave badly. They obviously can. The problem is that their bad behavior cannot automatically be attributed to the developmental structure of Green itself. This distinction should be familiar to anyone who studies developmental psychology. A person's developmental orientation, personality traits, ideological commitments, and situational behavior are related but not interchangeable variables. The Weaponization of Developmental LanguageThe most compelling section of Todorovic's paper may actually be its criticism of how the MGM label is used. On page 10, she describes the weaponization of Spiral Dynamics colors. Instead of serving as relatively neutral descriptors of different value systems, they become instruments of classification and exclusion. Critics of integral philosophy can be dismissed as Mean Green without their arguments receiving serious consideration. Their objections are interpreted as symptoms of developmental pathology rather than as potentially legitimate intellectual disagreements. This creates a convenient rhetorical mechanism. If someone criticizes Wilber, the criticism can be explained away as Green resentment, resistance to hierarchy, or an inability to recognize higher developmental levels. The theory thereby becomes protected against criticism by the very terminology that supposedly makes it more sophisticated. Todorovic calls this form of behavior a kind of Spiral classism, comparing it to other systems of prejudice. Her criticism is that developmental language, originally intended to improve understanding, can become a tool for denigrating people. She illustrates this with Wilber's own account of the reception of Boomeritis. In an interview, Wilber characterized critical Green responses to his book as angry and vicious, while describing sympathetic Turquoise responses as supportive and appreciative. Todorovic finds this revealing. The critics are classified as Green, while the supporters are elevated to Turquoise. The obvious problem is that agreement with the author becomes an implicit indicator of developmental advancement. This is a deeply questionable procedure. A critic might be right or wrong regardless of developmental classification. Equally, a sympathetic reader might be insightful or mistaken. Developmental theory should not become a system for awarding higher status to those who agree with its principal exponent. There is a particularly troubling consequence here: the more strongly someone questions the theory, the more easily that questioning can be interpreted as evidence of the very developmental limitations the theory attributes to them. This is not a scientific response to criticism. It is a form of immunization against criticism. Where Todorovic's Argument Is Less ConvincingDespite its considerable merits, the paper is not the definitive empirical refutation its title might suggest. First, the research design has limitations. Todorovic provides correlations, rejection scores, selected profiles, and summary statistics, but readers are not given the complete dataset or sufficient methodological detail to independently reproduce the analysis. We are told that the initial analysis covers more than 600 profiles, while some of the charts concern smaller samples, including 148 profiles with elevated Green rejection. The top-20 and top-40 comparisons are also based on particularly extreme rejection scores. These distinctions matter. The sample selection, representativeness, reliability of the instrument, and validity of the classifications all require closer examination. Second, rejection of a value system is not necessarily equivalent to perceiving it as mean or pathological. Someone might reject Green because they personally prefer hierarchy, individual achievement, or traditional authority. That does not necessarily mean they believe Green is dangerous or malicious. Conversely, someone might accept Green's general values while recognizing that particular Green-oriented movements can become intolerant, coercive, or self-righteous. The relationship between rejection scores and perceptions of meanness is therefore not straightforward. Third, the paper sometimes moves from statistical associations to psychological interpretations rather quickly. For example, its suggestion that Orange-oriented thinking explains the emergence of MGM is an interesting hypothesis, but the presented correlations do not establish the motivations of those who developed or popularized the concept. The same methodological caution applies to the Yellow false-positive argument. It may identify a genuine weakness in the instrument, but it does not demonstrate that MGM proponents are systematically misclassified. Finally, Todorovic occasionally uses the very developmental classifications she criticizes to explain the shortcomings of her opponents. Her suggestion that Blue/Orange thinking is responsible for the MGM phenomenon risks reproducing the same kind of reductive labeling. If MGM should not be used to dismiss critics, neither should Orange or Blue become convenient explanations for those who promote it. The strongest argument in this paper is not that MGM advocates belong to a particular developmental category. It is that their claims require independent evidence and should not be accepted simply because they are presented in the language of developmental theory. Wilber's Cultural Diagnosis: A Different Question?There is another issue that deserves consideration. Todorovic largely evaluates MGM as a proposition about Gravesian value systems and their characteristic psychological configurations. But Wilber's Boomeritis can also be read as a cultural critique of certain tendencies within contemporary Western liberal and progressive movements. These are not necessarily identical questions. It is possible that Wilber has incorrectly attributed particular psychological characteristics to the Green value system while nevertheless identifying recognizable problems in some movements associated with egalitarianism and pluralism. For example, ideological conformity, moralistic intolerance, hostility toward expertise, and the suppression of dissent are not exclusive to Green. They can occur in religious fundamentalism, nationalist movements, revolutionary politics, and technocratic institutions. Indeed, they can appear in virtually any ideological environment where group identity becomes more important than critical examination. The important question is therefore not whether Green can be mean. Of course it can. The question is whether there is something specifically Green about the particular forms of intolerance Wilber describes. Todorovic's research casts serious doubt on the assumption that these characteristics follow naturally from the Green developmental system. But it does not establish that every cultural phenomenon Wilber associates with Boomeritis is imaginary. A more defensible approach would be to investigate specific behaviors and institutions without presuming their developmental origins. The Larger Integral Problem: Developmental Theory as Ideological ProtectionThe controversy surrounding the Mean Green Meme illustrates a larger problem within Integral Theory. Wilber's developmental framework promises to explain why people disagree, why certain perspectives emerge historically, and why some forms of thinking can encompass more complexity than others. But this explanatory ambition creates a danger: disagreement can become developmental evidence. If someone disagrees with an integral proposition, the disagreement can be classified as a lower-level response. If someone criticizes the theory, the criticism can be interpreted as resistance to higher development. If someone agrees with the theory, that agreement can be interpreted as evidence of greater developmental maturity. The result is an asymmetrical intellectual environment in which the theory's advocates enjoy a privileged position. This is particularly problematic because the developmental categories themselves are not always independently established. Spiral Dynamics is a useful interpretive framework, but its colors should not be treated as objectively measurable psychological identities without adequate validation. Nor should the framework be confused with a universal ranking system for evaluating the intellectual worth of individuals. The MGM controversy exposes the danger of turning a developmental model into a social status hierarchy. There is an additional irony. A philosophy that emphasizes the transcendence and inclusion of earlier perspectives should be especially capable of engaging criticism without reducing critics to their presumed developmental limitations. When it does otherwise, it risks contradicting its own aspirations. Conclusion: A Useful Correction, Not the Final WordNatasha Todorovic's The Mean Green Hypothesis: Fact or Fiction? remains an important contribution to the debate about Ken Wilber's interpretation of Spiral Dynamics. Its greatest achievement is to question whether the Mean Green Meme can legitimately be attributed to Clare Graves's developmental theory. Her empirical findings suggest that the strongest rejection of Green comes predominantly from Blue and Orange orientations, not from Yellow. She also challenges the supposed Red-Green combination, questions the attribution of aggressive personality characteristics to Green, and exposes the potential misuse of developmental terminology as a means of dismissing intellectual opponents. Her criticism of the weaponization of Spiral Dynamics colors is especially relevant beyond the original controversy. Nevertheless, the research has limitations. Its data and instruments do not conclusively establish the motivations of MGM proponents, nor do they rule out the possibility that some cultural movements associated with Green exhibit recognizable pathological tendencies. The proper conclusion is therefore somewhat more restrained than Todorovic's own. The Mean Green Meme has not been demonstrated as a distinct and empirically established developmental pathology. Wilber's use of the concept in Boomeritis is theoretically underdeveloped and insufficiently supported by Gravesian research. And its use as a rhetorical device to disqualify critics is intellectually indefensible. But the broader phenomenon of ideological intolerance deserves investigation independently of Spiral Dynamics. Perhaps the most important lesson is that no developmental framework should be allowed to exempt itself from the standards of evidence, consistency, and critical examination that it applies to others. If integral philosophy wants to transcend simplistic thinking, it should begin by resisting the temptation to classify every disagreement as evidence of developmental inferiority. The Mean Green Meme may ultimately tell us less about the pathology of Green than about the dangers of turning a theory of human development into an instrument of intellectual self-protection. Overall assessmentTodorovic's paper is particularly valuable for three reasons: 1. It challenges the empirical foundations of MGM. Her rejection-pattern data provide a serious counterargument to the claim that Green's supposed pathology is primarily recognized by more advanced developmental perspectives. 2. It identifies a problem of theoretical immunization. The use of developmental labels to dismiss critics is one of the most serious problems in Wilber's intellectual culture. 3. It distinguishes developmental structures from personality and behavior. This is an important methodological correction that applies well beyond Spiral Dynamics. One qualification is important: the paper dates from 2002. Its findings should not be treated as a definitive contemporary validation study of Spiral Dynamics or as a final verdict on the cultural phenomena Wilber was trying to describe. My verdict: Todorovic makes a persuasive case against treating the Mean Green Meme as an established Gravesian developmental pathology. Her strongest contribution, however, is philosophical rather than statistical: she exposes how developmental language can become a mechanism for protecting an intellectual system from criticism. And that is arguably the more enduring issue. Appendix: Wilber's Second-Tier Green Allergy: A Curious ReversalThere is an interesting development in Ken Wilber's treatment of Green in his 2017 book The Religion of Tomorrow. Fifteen years after the controversy surrounding the Mean Green Meme, Wilber introduces another developmental pathology that deserves attention: "A very common pathology at 2nd tierperhaps even the most commonis a green allergy. With a green allergy, the 2nd tier individual, sick and tired of the extreme green culture that he or she had to fight so hard in order to emerge into Integral, simply dissociates and disowns any and all of its remaining green impulses and qualities, and projects them onto the world at large, and then the "mean green meme" seems to be absolutely everywhere. As always, the projection of a shadow element makes the presence of that shadow element in the world seem enormously greater than it really is, and this certainly happens with the green allergy that 2nd tier often develops" (p. 332) This statement is particularly interesting when read alongside his earlier criticism of Green in Boomeritis (2002) and Natasha Todorovic's subsequent challenge to the Mean Green Meme hypothesis. From Mean Green to Green AllergyWilber's developmental psychology of pathology includes two complementary concepts: addiction and allergy. An addiction occurs when someone remains excessively attached to a developmental stage, while an allergy occurs when someone rejects or represses it. Applied to Green, this produces an interesting reversal. In Boomeritis, Wilber argues that Green has become pathological through its excessive attachment to pluralism, egalitarianism and relativism. Its supposed combination with Red narcissism obstructs the emergence of Second-Tier consciousness. In The Religion of Tomorrow, however, he identifies an equally serious problem on the other side: people who have reached Second Tier can become excessively allergic to Green. In other words, those who have supposedly transcended Green may nevertheless remain psychologically entangled with it through their rejection of it. This is a potentially useful observation. Developmental transcendence should not mean contempt for the developmental stages that precede it. A genuinely more inclusive perspective ought to recognize the contributions of Green without becoming captive to its limitations. But there is an obvious question: how do we distinguish a legitimate criticism of Green from an unhealthy allergy to it? A Convenient Double Standard?The juxtaposition of these two arguments creates an interesting problem for Wilber's critics. If someone defends Green against Wilber's characterization, that person can be classified as exhibiting Mean Green tendencies. If someone criticizes Green, that criticism might be interpreted as an expression of a Second-Tier Green allergy. This creates a remarkably flexible interpretive framework. Green can be criticized, but criticism of Green can itself be criticized as pathological. The danger is that the theory becomes difficult to challenge from either direction. Of course, Wilber could reasonably argue that both phenomena exist. Green can become excessively self-righteous, and people claiming to have transcended Green can become dismissive and intolerant of it. There is no logical contradiction in recognizing both possibilities. But this requires independent criteria for identifying each pathology. Otherwise, developmental terminology becomes a convenient way of interpreting any disagreement as psychological dysfunction. Does This Explain Wilber's Relationship with His Critics?The passage also invites a more personal question. For decades, Wilber has had a difficult relationship with critics who question his philosophical, scientific and developmental claims. His tendency to characterize certain objections as Green reactions raises the possibility that he himself might exhibit precisely the pathology he identifies on page 332: an allergy to Green. This is not a psychological diagnosis. It is a question of intellectual consistency. If Second-Tier thinkers are particularly susceptible to Green allergies, then Wilber himself cannot be exempt from that possibility. Indeed, the more strongly he insists that his critics are developmentally stuck, the more important it becomes to examine whether his own response reflects an inability to appreciate legitimate Green contributions. There is also an irony in the fact that Todorovic's 2002 paper was written from within the Gravesian tradition and attempted to defend the theoretical integrity of Spiral Dynamics against what she considered an unjustified Wilberian modification. One might expect an integral thinker to welcome such an internal correction. The Deeper LessonWilber's observation about Second-Tier Green allergy could actually be turned into a useful corrective to his earlier treatment of the Mean Green Meme. A developmental perspective should neither idealize Green nor demonize it. It should recognize its genuine achievements, its limitations, and the possibility that supposedly more advanced perspectives can develop their own pathologies. But this principle must apply equally to Wilber himself. The question is not whether Green can be mean or whether Second Tier can become allergic to Green. Both are plausible. The question is whether Wilber applies the same critical standards to his own developmental position that he applies to everyone else. If the answer is no, then the problem may not be Green's pathology at all, but the pathology of a theory that too easily turns disagreement into evidence of developmental deficiency.
Comment Form is loading comments...
|

Frank Visser, graduated as a psychologist of culture and religion, founded IntegralWorld in 1997. He worked as production manager for various publishing houses and as service manager for various internet companies and lives in Amsterdam. Books: 