Search through thousands of pages on Integral Theory
TRANSLATE THIS ARTICLE
Integral World: Exploring Theories of Everything
An independent forum for a critical discussion of the integral philosophy of Ken Wilber

More essays by Ray Harris

Ray HarrisRay Harris is a frequent contributor to this website. He has written articles on 9/11, boomeritis, the Iraq war and Third Way politics. Since 2007 he took to writing his novels Navaratri, Wild Child and Eden. Harris lives in Ballarat, Victoria, Australia.



The Development Trap 'Trap'

Dillard's Sleight of Hand

Ray Harris

In his most recent essay "When Good Intentions Preserve Harm" Dillard invokes my name. He quotes my 2007 essay Integral Notes on the Israel/Arab Conflict, however, as usual, he quotes me out of context. I'll address that misrepresentation later.

The purpose of this essay is to point out how he misrepresents developmental psychology and slips into the very same trap he accuses others of falling into.

Natural versus dominator hierarchies

I'm relearning the guitar. There are two aspects to this relearning. The theoretical and the practical. I'd confidently say that I'm transitioning from beginner to intermediate. I am certainly nowhere near master or virtuoso level and don't expect to ever achieve those heights. I'm happy to plod along making gradual improvements.

This is to say that there is a clear developmental hierarchy to learning any musical instrument. In classical music there are masters and students, examinations and grades, success and failure.

It is the same in almost every skill or trade. If you want to attain that skill there is a process of staged learning under the guidance of a teacher who knows more than you do. Some people advance through those stages faster than others, but you can't skip a stage.

Using the example of music how do we explain the existence of child prodigies? They are not the result of trickery. They are very real. We can watch them perform. Consider Alma Deutscher, a violin and piano prodigy who wrote her first piano sonata at age 5, her first short opera at 7, her first violin concerto at 9 and her first full length opera at 10. Now aged 21, she is an internationally recognised composer and conductor. She has done many interviews in which she comes across as polite, humble and very bright. Oh, and she is also fluent in three languages. All of which indicates she is highly advanced across several developmental lines.

The simple fact is that there are people who are faster, stronger, fitter, smarter and more talented than others. There are also people who are more knowledgeable and experienced and we defer to their expertise in the relevant circumstances. If I want my car fixed I'm going to take it to a qualified mechanic.

These stages of development can be objectively measured.

However, a problem arises when someone with a greater ability or expertise assumes this qualifies them in other areas. It is a common human failing that people often abuse their position of authority to gain an egotistical, financial, sexual or sadistic benefit. How many music teachers have abused their students?

Dominator hierarchies are hierarchies of power and abuse.

These abuses of power happen across all disciplines and fields. Employers abuse employees, teachers abuse students, doctors abuse patients, financial advisors abuse clients, and so on. The courts regularly deal with such abuses.

This abuse is particularly rife in religious organisations where the abuser hides behind some alleged divine authority. In Kenya a self-appointed pastor, Paul Mackenzie instructed his followers to starve themselves to death in order to meet Jesus, resulting in the death of more than four hundred of his followers.

We've seen this before - many times.

It is therefore hardly surprising that several spiritual leaders linked to Ken Wilber have been found guilty of abusing their authority. It's hardly unique to the Integral community.

And as Dillard must know, it also happens in his field of psychotherapy, which has had its fair share of quackery and therapist-patient abuse.

Higher development doesn't guarantee being right

This is something of a red herring because I have never encountered anyone who believes that a higher level of development means you are automatically right. Highly developed individuals can make appalling mistakes.

But we have to be realistic here. Someone with greater knowledge, more experience and who is at a higher level of development is less likely to make the mistakes than someone with less knowledge and experience who is at a lower level of development.

Time to be honest. Would you rather be advised by experienced people with above average intelligence or inexperienced people with below average intelligence?

The problem of self-assessment

Developmental psychologists understand that a set of objective standards is necessary to assess an individual's developmental level. This is also the case in some spiritual traditions, particularly in Hinduism and Buddhism, which outline levels of attainment to be assessed by an authorised teacher.

A problem arises when individuals step outside the system of testing and simply assert they have attained this or that level.

It is also possible for a developmental system to fail to maintain a rigorous methodology. I would argue this has happened to Graves's original work on values under Don Beck's reformulation, Spiral Dynamics.

The reason methodological rigour is essential is that it ego inflation is common. It is typical for the ego to inflate an individual's measurable level of development - to assume it has a higher IQ than it does, is more moral, or more spiritually developed.

Dillard has created his own hierarchy

Dillard has been clear about his priorities. In his recent essay Developmental Ranking Across Integral, Metamodern and Spiritual Cultures He states:

“Cognitive multi-perspectivalism has been abundant in integral and post-integral movements; empathetic multi-perspectivalism, something I have elaborated in a number of Integral World essays, has been less evident.”

It is clear he wants to place his concept of empathetic multi-perspectivalism as at least equal or higher level compared to cognitive multi-perspectivalism.

But is he correct to say that Integral ignores empathy?

Empathy in developmental psychology

By definition Integral means integrating multiple perspectives. This necessarily includes studies in the development of empathy.

Here two names are important, Carol Gilligan and Martin L Hoffman - Dillard is aware of both of them.

Carol Gilligan exposed a gender bias in Kohlberg's system of moral development. She makes a distinction between a masculine ethics of justice and a feminine ethics of care. Following Kohlberg's levels:

Pre-conventional Stage (Orientation to Individual Survival): The individual is focused on self-interest, survival, and what is best for oneself.

Conventional Stage (Goodness as Self-Sacrifice): Morality is equated with caring for others and societal/maternal expectations, often resulting in complete self-sacrifice where a person ignores their own needs.

Post-conventional Stage (The Morality of Nonviolence/Ethics of Care): Reaching a balance where care for oneself and care for others are integrated.

Martin L Hoffman studied the moral development of children. He defined five stages from infant to late childhood. Late childhood is defined as:

“Individuals can feel empathy for someone's broader life condition, chronic struggles, or group-wide plight—even when the person is not visibly distressed in the immediate moment. Advances in abstract thinking and identity allow people to form mental representations of ongoing circumstances (such as poverty, illness, or injustice) and connect empathy to moral principles.”

Note that Hoffman acknowledges that advances in abstract thinking assist the individual in expanding their moral concern.

This tells us that cognitive development is paired with the development of empathy. An imbalance occurs when one is preferred over the other.

Conflict resolution

My pathway into developmental psychology and Wilber's synthesis was through understanding and implementing conflict resolution in activist organisations.

I have stated many times that it is my preference that all conflict be resolved through a formal conflict resolution process similar to South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission. It is my wish that Israel and Palestine institute a similar process. But I am not naive. Such a process can only work if both sides agree and at the moment both sides have chosen force through violence.

For any conflict resolution process to succeed all parties must utilise both cognitive and empathetic skills.

For a more detailed explanation see my essay Against Political Violence

Dillard's sleight of hand

Dillard's complaint is that those in the Integral, Metamodern and Spiritual cultures place a greater emphasis on cognitive development and not enough on empathetic development.

I could not disagree more.

I see no evidence of a lack of empathy.

What I do see however, is a disagreement over the causes of geopolitical conflict and the best ways to resolve that conflict.

Here Dillard performs the same ranking move he accuses the Integral movement of. He assumes a morally superior position and argues that those who disagree with him are less empathetically developed.

If you disagree with him over the Israel/Palestine or Russian/Ukraine conflicts he judges that you lack sufficient empathy.

Dillard's poor moral judgment

Yes, Dillard actually went there. In his 2019 essay Integral Groupthink he entertained Holocaust denial. I hope he has changed his position.

He says:

“The Holocaust killed 6 million Jews.

“Inconvenient truths indicate that this number is highly unlikely, but whatever the number, it was far less than some 20 million people killed by the US in illegal wars since WWII.[20, 21] Again, groupthink means that one can be accused of “hate speech” and anti-Semitism, arrested, and imprisoned for merely questioning this sacrosanct manufactured narrative. Legislation in the US is now criminalizing same in the US, making the questioning of groupthink a crime and those who do so criminals.[22]”

In his notes he reveals that the source for this bullshit is Ron Unz, a notorious holocaust denier. Had Dillard done his due diligence he would have discovered the lie at the heart of Unz's claim:

“…for decades I had always read the undeniable fact that the Nazis had exterminated 4 million inmates at Auschwitz, with most of the victims being Jews, and Lipstadt certainly treated that number as absolutely rock-solid historical reality. But in the early 1990s after the fall of Communism, the official total was quietly revised downwards to as little as 1.1 million. The fact that a sudden reduction in the official Holocaust body-count by 3 million has had so little impact upon our public Holocaust media narrative hardly seems to inspire great confidence in either the total figures or the media reporting of them.”

As with most conspiratorial disinformation the lie contains a sliver of truth, in this case it is true that Russia revised their estimate of the deaths at Auschwitz from 4 million down to 1.1 million. However, the lie is that the original Russian estimation was used to calculate the total of 6 million. It wasn't. Holocaust scholars, including Lipstadt, did not use the Soviet figures, considering them grossly exaggerated.

As for the claim that the US has killed around 20 million people, again discredited nonsense posted on a notorious anti-vaxx conspiracy website, Global Research, in which the editor makes this extraordinary claim:

“In turn, in response to a non-existent pandemic the Covid-19 “Vaccine” which was launched in mid-December 2020 has resulted in millions of deaths Worldwide.”

Does Dillard ever check his sources? He consistently falls for disinformation and propaganda from both far left and far right sources. This has been demonstrated time and time again by multiple critics.

Dillard does not follow his own advice

Towards the end of his essay he repeats one of his recent formulations:

“The relevant question is whether the participants in these debates can suspend the ranking move long enough to inhabit the perspectives they are dismissing, allow those perspectives to challenge their own assumptions, and revise behavior and allegiance when the evidence and the competing goods require it. That capacity—participatory maturity rather than altitude identity—is the book's measure of developmental seriousness.”

This is a clear case of mirroring. The rhetorical device of accusing others of the very thing you are guilty of.

Despite being corrected on multiple occasions, Dillard continues to cling to his preferred narrative. He stubbornly resists 'new information' that might challenge his assumptions and he certainly fails to revise his behaviour and allegiances. He does not meet his own test of 'participatory maturity' and instead relies on his own form of 'altitude identity' based on empathy.

This mirroring is the most evident in his allegation that the Integral community has fallen into the error of groupthink when he is the one who has fallen for the conspiratorial groupthink of the alternative media (see my essay The Tower of Babel for a more comprehensive examination of media bias).

The most recent example of this was his decision to post a meme that repeated several of the lies he has been consistently spreading about the Ukraine war, which Visser comprehensively demolished in Debunking the Pro-Russian Meme.

We are not talking about contrasting opinions here. We are talking about Dillard's rejection of objective, documented evidence.

Misunderstanding human development and evolution

Dillard makes this nonsensical observation:

“The central evolutionary claim of The Development Trap undercuts the move's authority. Hierarchical complexity is real; however, it is not therefore evolution's highest value. Evolution possesses no intrinsic preference for expansion over collapse, development over extinction, intelligence over ignorance, or complexification over simplicity. It preserves whatever remains adaptively viable under changing conditions.”

This is the fallacy of division - assuming that what is true for the whole is true for a part of the whole.

Whilst it is true that evolution possesses no intrinsic preference, it is not true that human evolution has no preference.

It is blatantly clear that humans adapted to evolutionary pressure by developing hierarchical complexity. We didn't adapt by shifting sideways or becoming simpler organisms. We created complex civilisations, developed sophisticated ways of communicating and invented elaborate forms of technology to assist us.

We created a complex world and in that complex world the ability to understand and manage complexity is a distinct advantage.

Even more nonsense

Dillard compounds his error by making another nonsensical statement:

“Highly sophisticated moral and developmental frameworks can become rigid precisely because of their sophistication. They invest more energy in preserving identity and narrative coherence than in revising them when new information or competing legitimate goods appear. The ranking of entire nations, movements, or critics by stage or metameme is a pure expression of this rigidity.”

This is simply false - and absurd. Here Dillard mistakes the map for the territory, the framework for what it measures.

The opposite is true. Developmentally advanced individuals show a greater ability not only to incorporate new information, but to invent new ways of doing things. It is the less developed that exhibit behavioural and cognitive rigidity.

It's all just an elaborate rationalisation

Dillard delivers the punch line at the end:

“By that measure, the recent debates over Israel/Gaza and Ukraine/Russia have revealed how easily even sophisticated spiritual frameworks revert to the very ethnocentric and identity-protective dynamics they claim to have transcended.”

This is a bold assertion for which he provides no evidence whatsoever.

What he is really saying here is that if you disagree with his position in these debates then you have reverted to 'ethnocentric and identity protective dynamics'.

I'd call this gaslighting.

It is my observation that the reason people disagree with Dillard on these issues is that he is often just plain wrong.

Addressing his misrepresentation of my essay

Dillard summarises my views on the Israel Palestine conflict:

“Within Integral circles, Ray Harris framed Israeli society as possessing greater developmental span than surrounding Arab cultures and invoked the prime directive to prioritize that span. Harris argued that “Israeli society has a greater developmental span than the traditional Arab culture it replaced. Under Arab domination there is a high likelihood this developmental depth would eventually be lost.”

The best way to address this misrepresentation is by providing the quote in its proper context - the quote appears in bold.

“With the likely collapse of a Palestinian state the option that best serves the prime directive is a secure Israeli state and it is here we face another inconvenient truth. Israeli society has a greater developmental span than the traditional Arab culture it replaced. Under Arab domination there is a high likelihood this developmental depth would eventually be lost.

“I understand that this statement is likely to offend some. What about the oppression of the Palestinians by the Israeli state? Surely that is stunting their development? I agree, it is. But the prime directive demands growth for the greatest number, not just a select group.

“Much as it is distasteful to suppress a people there may be no choice if that group's freedom means that an even greater number of people suffer. Whilst Palestinians continue to embrace political violence their neighbours (including Palestinian minorities) have no choice but to try and defend themselves. As long as a significant percentage of Palestinians support the destruction of the Israeli state what choice do Israelis have? The argument is therefore not really that Israelis have a right to defend themselves but how they execute that right. In which case there is no right answer to a subjective question of degree. Some will argue that the Israelis go too far and some say not far enough. Where is the balance point and who is wise enough to know (we all have the wisdom of armchair hindsight)?”

For further clarification please note that I was careful to say 'traditional Arab culture' and not Palestinians. Under Ottoman rule the local Arab culture was feudal, with an educated elite governing a largely illiterate rural population. Demographic data was not collected so it is hard to calculate the exact rate of illiteracy, but one estimate puts it as high as 98%. This situation was dramatically reversed under British and Israeli occupation so that now there is only a 2% illiteracy rate (mostly amongst the elderly).






PLEASE NOTE: Comments containing links are not allowed, to avoid spam.


Comment Form is loading comments...