• home
• about
• new
• essays
• AI
• book

David Christopher Lane, Ph.D, is a Professor of Philosophy at Mt. San Antonio College and Founder of the MSAC Philosophy Group. He is the author of several books, including The Sound Current Tradition (Cambridge University Press, 2022) and the graphic novel, The Cult of the Seven Sages, translated into Tamil (Kannadhasan Pathippagam, 2024). His website is neuralsurfer.com

The Stigmata in Chinatown

A Transcendent Disruption

David Lane

Preface.

I was in San Francisco this month for a two-fold reason. One, to drive my youngest son Kelly back to U.C. Berkeley, where he is currently a junior, and, two, to see my oldest son Shaun who had flown back from Hong Kong to set up his new start-up company with his two Stanford University friends (fingers crossed). My wife, Andrea, and I were planning on a small break from teaching and hopefully explore various old haunts, particularly our favorite bookstores, such as Moe's and City Lights.

However, I never expected that a chance encounter at a small Catholic chapel would have such a dramatic impact on me. The following narrative, forged as it was by a strange serendipity, convinced me that the world we presently inhabit is undergoing a change that will upend everything we think we know about ourselves and the universe.

I won't reveal more now but will let this story serve as an appetizer.

CHAPTER 1. A Chance Encounter

The clang of a nearby cable car rattled the early spring air in San Francisco's Chinatown. Dr. Oliver Hastings, a world-renowned neuroscientist, exhaled as he checked his watch. It was just past three o'clock in the afternoon on Good Friday. For reasons he couldn't entirely explain, Oliver had felt a nagging sense of restlessness all day, as though something momentous were about to happen. Normally on a Friday he would be holed up in the neural imaging lab at Stanford, calibrating the latest fMRI scans and puzzling over anomalies in consciousness studies. Yet here he was, wandering the maze-like streets in the city, letting an unplanned walk lead him wherever it chose.

A few minutes earlier, his mind had caught some half-remembered mention of a small replica of the Porziuncola—St. Francis of Assisi's tiny chapel—built in San Francisco near North Beach, not too far from Chinatown. Oliver had heard a colleague mention it, describing it as a curious hidden gem of architecture and faith. On a whim, he decided to search for it. A quick glance at his phone revealed it was inside the National Shrine of St. Francis of Assisi, only a short walk from where he stood near the dragon gates of Chinatown.

“Why not?” he said to himself, skipping over the fact that he was not a religious man. Curiosity alone compelled him; he had always loved architecture, and he enjoyed the meditative hush of old churches.

He passed beneath the painted eaves of a gate, scanning the shop signs in both Mandarin and English. He checked the directions on his phone once more. The cathedral building loomed ahead, its façade a combination of Italian Renaissance elements with a distinctly Californian flair. Next to it, tucked almost unassumingly, stood a smaller, rustic stone chapel. To Oliver, it seemed as if an ancient site from medieval Umbria had been lifted brick by brick and set down here, amongst the bustle of the modern city.

He slipped into the chapel through an arched wooden door, and the noise of San Francisco's busy streets abruptly faded. Soft light filtered through colored glass windows, casting blues and greens over the pews. There was a single occupant: a middle-aged woman in a black coat, praying silently in the front row. Oliver moved quietly to avoid disturbing her. At the rear of the chapel, he stopped in front of a small display containing a row of pamphlets and postcards depicting scenes of St. Francis.

But something else caught his attention: a portrait of a bearded man in a brown Capuchin robe, his eyes seemingly filled with both suffering and compassion. Above the image read the words Padre Pio. Oliver squinted, trying to recall if he had heard of him before. He vaguely remembered references to someone named Padre Pio who was rumored to have carried the stigmata, the wounds of Christ, in the twentieth century. Next to that photograph was a depiction of St. Francis himself, arms outstretched toward a seraphic vision, five wounds visible on hands, feet, and side.

He recalled reading once that St. Francis of Assisi was the first to be historically recorded as having the stigmata. The science-minded part of Oliver's brain had always dismissed such stories as products of intense devotion, mass hysteria, or psychosomatic phenomena. But he had never studied the phenomenon in depth. A small sign below the pictures read:

“The stigmata, from the Greek for 'brand' or 'mark,' refers to bodily marks resembling the wounds of the crucified Christ. St. Francis was the first recorded stigmatist in Christian history…”

Oliver glanced around and noticed a caretaker entering from a side door. He was an older man, probably in his seventies, wearing a simple sweater and khaki pants.

“Good afternoon,” the caretaker said. “A beautiful chapel, isn't it?”

“It's extraordinary,” Oliver responded politely, turning from the portrait of Padre Pio. “I never imagined there was such a place in San Francisco.”

“Not many people do,” the caretaker answered. “But it's a special place. People from all over the world come to visit, especially those devoted to St. Francis and his spirit of humility.”

Oliver nodded. “I was just reading about the stigmata. I've heard of it, of course, but is it actually…documented?”

The caretaker gave a gentle smile. “It is. St. Francis received it in the early 1200s on Mount Alverna. The Church has recognized the phenomenon not just with Francis, but with other holy individuals, most famously Padre Pio in the twentieth century.”

“Padre Pio.” Oliver repeated, glancing at the portrait again. “It's almost unbelievable. My background is in neuroscience, so I'd usually consider it psychosomatic or somehow psychologically induced. But still, it's fascinating.”

“Yes, it is. We don't always comprehend the mysteries of faith with our ordinary senses,” said the caretaker. “Sometimes mysteries remain mysteries.”

Oliver thanked him, then wandered closer to the sanctuary. He inhaled the hush of the place, the faint aroma of old incense, dust, and candle wax. A swirling, surprising curiosity rose within him. He sat for a moment in one of the pews, letting the stillness rest in his bones. No mystic visions arose for him, of course. Only a slight sense of longing, a subtle wonder at how those men—St. Francis or Padre Pio—felt when they allegedly bore those wounds.

After a few more minutes of silent reflection, he stood to leave. He nodded a quiet farewell to the caretaker, stepping back into the late afternoon sunlight.

Everything that followed, he would later recall, hinged on that impulsive decision to visit the Porziuncola chapel.

CHAPTER 2. Good Friday Evening

Oliver's walk back through Chinatown took him past fish markets, produce stalls, and herbal shops. Steam rose from dim sum stands. He bought himself a small bun stuffed with red bean paste, half-lost in thought about stigmata and miracles. Though he was ordinarily a skeptic, something about the story of Padre Pio stirred him.

He caught a bus toward his apartment on Nob Hill. The jostling city scenes—tourists snapping photos of the Bay, office workers clutching briefcases, families meandering along the sidewalks—reminded him of how diverse and vibrant San Francisco was. He tried to push the notion of stigmata from his mind, but he couldn't entirely; the idea of psychosomatic wounds capturing centuries of devotion piqued his scientific curiosity.

He arrived at his apartment building, a stately Victorian with a wrought-iron gate and tall windows. Letting himself into his unit, he placed his keys on the kitchen counter and kicked off his shoes. A half-formed resolution bubbled up: maybe he would do a little reading about Padre Pio's stigmata tonight. But first, he wanted to freshen up. It had been a warm day, and the walk had left him sweaty.

He turned on the shower, letting the steam fill the bathroom. The day had been long. He stepped into the warm spray, letting it wash away his tension. Dusk cast dim shadows through the frosted window. He exhaled deeply and closed his eyes, letting his mind drift back to the chapel—St. Francis's stigmata, the devotion and skepticism that had swirled around Padre Pio…

Then, suddenly, he felt a small sting at the center of his right palm. “Ow,” he muttered, opening his eyes to see what he'd brushed against. Nothing. The tile wall was slick but not sharp. Perhaps a random nerve twinge or a cut from earlier?

He glanced at his hand more carefully—and froze. A thin rivulet of blood trickled from a puncture-like wound in the center of his palm. He turned it over in the water, half-convinced it must be a scratch or open blister. But the wound was exactly in the center. And something about the shape and depth set his pulse racing.

With a trembling gesture, he brought his other palm under the water. His breath caught in his throat as he saw an identical wound, also leaking fresh blood. The shower's water, pink-streaked, rushed around his feet. Shocked, Oliver immediately thought: I must have scraped my hands on something. But there was nothing sharp in the shower. And who scrapes both palms in the exact same spot?

Heart pounding, he turned off the water and stepped out, grabbing a towel. He stared down at his feet—and almost screamed. There were two small puddles of blood where his feet had been. A quick check revealed that the undersides of both of his feet, near the center, had shallow but alarmingly distinct wounds. A wave of dizziness overtook him. This can't be real.

He pressed the towel against his palms to stanch the bleeding. In seconds, the towel was speckled red. As he examined his reflection in the medicine cabinet mirror, a million thoughts spun inside him. Could this be an advanced allergic reaction? A bizarre spontaneous hemorrhage? The word stigmata thundered in his ears.

“No,” he whispered, voice shaking. “Impossible.”

But the blood was there, on his towel, on the shower floor. And the wounds were so precisely placed, it was uncanny. Oliver's breathing quickened, and a faint ringing filled his ears. He forced himself to steady, to think like a scientist. He had to go to the ER, get these wounds examined. Maybe some rare vascular condition was at play. That had to be it.

Clumsily dressing, he wrapped his feet with more towels, covering them enough to slip on loose-fitting sandals. He had to hail a cab. He couldn't very well walk all the way to the hospital in this condition. With shaking hands, he called for a rideshare. The minutes waiting in the lobby of his building felt like an eternity, each second accompanied by the dull ache from his palms and feet, each stab of pain a bizarre echo of what he had read in that chapel.

The car arrived, and he slid into the back seat, his heart pounding even harder with each passing block. He kept telling himself: There has to be a rational explanation. There has to be. Yet the caretaker's words returned to him, the references to miracles, to the stigmata. The combination was terrifying.

CHAPTER 3. Hospital and Doubt

St. Mary's Medical Center was usually quiet at this hour, but the hustle and bustle of the emergency department still churned. Nurses and orderlies hurried from one patient to another. Oliver limped inside, trying not to bleed on the polished floor. A nurse looked alarmed when she saw him, quickly escorting him to a curtained exam bay.

“What happened?” she asked as Oliver sat on the edge of a cot.

“I—I'm not entirely sure,” he stuttered, showing his hands and feet. “These, uh, wounds just…appeared.”

“Appeared?” She frowned. “Did you step on something sharp, or—”

“I was in the shower. Nothing around me could have caused this.”

The nurse's skeptical look was replaced by professional concern. She motioned to a colleague, and soon the staff began cleaning and dressing the wounds, drawing blood samples, hooking Oliver up to a vitals monitor. An ER doctor with salt-and-pepper hair named Dr. Morgan arrived, glancing over the partial dressings that had been applied.

“What do we have?” he asked the nurse.

“Puncture wounds to both palms and soles, symmetrical. Unknown cause, no foreign bodies visible. They're shallow, appear fresh, but we can't see any sign of external trauma. We're running labs now.”

Dr. Morgan turned to Oliver. “Could you describe precisely how these wounds appeared?”

Oliver swallowed. He realized how absurd it would sound, but he told the truth. “I was in the shower. I felt a sting in my right hand, looked down, and saw blood. Same on my left hand. Then I noticed my feet were bleeding, too.”

The doctor pressed his lips together. “No nails, no glass, no broken tile?”

“Nothing,” Oliver said. “I'm…a neuroscientist at Stanford. I'm aware how crazy this sounds. I even know about psychosomatic phenomena. But I can't see how you'd spontaneously develop open lacerations like these.”

The doctor touched one bandage gently. Oliver winced. “It's definitely unusual,” Dr. Morgan agreed, “but let's not jump to any conclusions. We'll do a thorough exam, maybe some imaging to see if anything foreign might be lodged in the tissue. Could be a bizarre coincidence or a spontaneously bleeding lesion. Let's do the science first.”

Two hours later, after various tests, the staff had no answers. X-rays showed no hidden shards. Blood tests showed normal platelets, normal clotting factors. The lab results revealed no infectious markers, no toxins. Blood pressure was fine. No sign of a neurological episode that might cause self-harm. Nothing. The wounds simply…existed.

Finally, Dr. Morgan returned, looking tired and perplexed. “I can't find a straightforward explanation,” he said quietly. “We can keep you overnight for observation or send you home with instructions. The wounds themselves are small, appear cauterized or partially sealed. This is truly bizarre.”

“That's putting it lightly,” Oliver murmured.

The doctor's voice lowered. “I'd like to consult with a psychiatrist as well, just to rule out any self-inflicted or dissociative issues. Would that be all right?”

“Yes,” Oliver replied, though he knew this was pointless. He was quite certain he hadn't inflicted these wounds on himself—at least not consciously, and it was still the strangest possibility he could conceive.

They had him speak to a staff psychiatrist, a gentle woman with wire-rim glasses who asked him about stress levels, depression, or mania. Oliver insisted, truthfully, that he felt stable. He had no history of mental illness. He was a scientist, with a rational mind, for heaven's sake. Yet here he was, bandaged like a man who had stepped straight from a medieval painting.

Eventually, around midnight, Dr. Morgan cleared him to go home. “Follow up with your primary care physician next week. Meanwhile, if anything changes—like any sign of infection or additional wounds—come right back.”

Oliver thanked him, though the thanks sounded hollow to his own ears. He still couldn't believe what was happening. Stigmata, he thought again as he left the hospital. But that word was too unnerving to dwell on. Instead, he focused on the scientific method: gather data, form hypotheses, test them. The only problem was that he was both scientist and unwitting experimental subject.

Back at his apartment, he collapsed on the couch, exhausted but too anxious to sleep. In the dim light of his living room, he opened his laptop and typed a single word into a search engine: stigmata.

CHAPTER 4. Skepticism Meets Faith

The search results were as Oliver expected: countless religious articles, Catholic websites, references to St. Francis of Assisi, Padre Pio, plus tabloid sensationalism about modern-day claimants to stigmatic phenomena. He clicked through scientific analyses that described psychological stigmata as a psychosomatic reaction. Certain psychiatrists had proposed that an intense focus on the Passion of Christ, combined with a deep emotional state, could manifest as real wounds. But Oliver did not focus on the Passion of Christ. He wasn't even a practicing Christian. The last time he had set foot in a church for a service was probably a wedding ten years ago.

He found medical debate swirling around the accounts of Padre Pio's stigmata—some said it was self-inflicted, others believed it was unexplainable. One particular anecdote amused him: a doubting physician told an Italian actor that Padre Pio's stigmata came from thinking too much about Christ's wounds, and when the actor told Pio that, Pio allegedly said, “Tell your doctor to think intensely about being an ox, let's see if he grows horns.”

Oliver shook his head. He was living that scenario in reverse; he was the skeptical scientist who had ended up with the inexplicable wounds. Leaning back, he stared at his bandaged palms. Weariness tugged at him. Maybe if he managed a few hours of sleep, he'd wake to find them gone, a dreadful hallucination. Yes, he thought, maybe I just need to rest.

But that night was restless. Each time he dozed, he dreamt of swirling incense, chanting monks, and an image of a crucified figure that blurred between Christ and a Franciscan friar. He woke repeatedly, heart pounding, tears inexplicably wetting his cheeks. When the dawn light finally pierced his curtains, he gave up on sleep altogether.

He decided to return to the Porziuncola chapel that morning, to see if perhaps the caretaker could offer any insight. It was a desperate notion, but what else could he do?

Taking a taxi, since his feet still ached, he arrived at the National Shrine of St. Francis just after the early Mass had ended. Parishioners trickled out, many greeting each other with “Happy Easter weekend,” though Easter Sunday was still two days away.

Oliver waited until the chapel was mostly empty and then went inside. The caretaker was there, kneeling in prayer. Oliver felt a twinge of guilt interrupting him, but he quietly cleared his throat. The older man turned, recognized Oliver, and stood.

“Sir, you're back,” he said kindly. “Is everything all right?”

Oliver hesitated, unsure how much to reveal. “I—I have something I need to talk about.” Wordlessly, he unwrapped the bandages on his left hand and offered his palm for the caretaker to see. A small, blood-stained circle sat in the center.

The caretaker's eyes widened with shock. “How did you…?”

“That's what I'm trying to figure out,” Oliver breathed. “I came here yesterday, saw the pictures of St. Francis and Padre Pio. I found the idea of stigmata interesting, though I'm not religious. Then I went home, and that evening—these wounds appeared. On my palms and my feet. No explanation from the hospital. They're just…there.”

The caretaker gently took Oliver's hand in his own, examining the wound. He glanced around to be sure no one else was in earshot. “This is…remarkable,” he whispered. “Have you—told anyone else besides the doctors?”

“No. I'm honestly overwhelmed,” Oliver admitted. “I'm a scientist. I don't believe in miracles, but this is beyond anything I can rationalize. If this is some kind of stigmata—well, it's impossible. Isn't it?”

The caretaker sighed softly. “Historically, many who received such wounds were devout Christians or people deeply devoted to the Passion of Christ. But God's ways are mysterious. I'm no theologian, though. I only know that stigmata is usually seen as a sign of profound participation in Christ's suffering.” He paused. “Tell me, do you think you might be called by God to something?”

Oliver almost laughed, but tears pricked his eyes instead. “Honestly? I have no idea. I'm not even sure I believe in God. I just… I need answers.”

“Perhaps you should speak to a Franciscan priest,” the caretaker said. “They may be able to direct you further, or at least help you pray about this. But you say you're a scientist. Don't abandon your methods, either. Keep searching medically. And… if you're open to it, keep searching spiritually.”

Oliver nodded, a swirl of confusion within him. “Thank you,” he murmured. “I appreciate your time.” He turned toward the exit, uncertain what to do next.

Outside, the sky was gray and cool. The caretaker's words lingered in Oliver's mind: Are you called by God to something? It rang as a question he had never bothered to pose to himself. Then he thought of the caretaker's parting advice: Don't abandon your methods, and keep searching spiritually. Oliver resolved to do exactly that. He would investigate scientifically, but he would also—for perhaps the first time in his life—allow the possibility that something beyond his normal understanding might be at work.

CHAPTER 5. Confrontations with Science

Oliver spent the next week in a haze of contradictory impulses. By day, he tried to proceed with his normal routine: teaching a graduate seminar on consciousness at Stanford, meeting with research assistants about the next round of fMRI experiments, reviewing data on neural correlates of religious experience. But at night, he found himself scouring obscure medical journals, emailing colleagues in psychosomatic medicine, even carefully reading about the stigmata of saints.

The bandages on his hands and feet needed changing daily, and to his frustration, the wounds showed no sign of infection—but also no sign of healing. They remained as fresh as the day they appeared, occasionally leaking traces of blood. The pain was mild but persistent, like a dull ache that reminded him of how his life had turned upside down. Occasionally, he felt a sharper stab if he pressed on them, or if he took too long a walk. It was enough to keep the phenomenon constantly in his awareness.

On the Friday after Easter, he went to see Dr. Miriam Nguyen, an immunologist and close colleague, hoping for her insights.

She looked at the wounds with a clinical eye. “I've never seen anything like this,” she admitted. “They're too regular. If these were auto-immune skin lesions, the pattern wouldn't be so symmetrical or so localized to the centers of the palms and feet. We could do a biopsy. That might reveal something at the tissue level.”

So they took small samples from Oliver's palms under local anesthetic. Oliver held his breath during the procedure, half-expecting something cosmic to happen, but nothing did. Just a mild sting and Dr. Nguyen's calm instructions.

A few days later, she called him: “The biopsy shows normal tissue, with no sign of infection or malignant cells. There's some evidence of micro-tearing, but it's inconclusive. No external agent we can see.”

“Meaning?”

“I don't know,” she said. “It doesn't look like typical self-inflicted wounds, though we can't rule it out entirely. I'm sorry, Oliver. I'm stumped.”

He thanked her and ended the call, left only with the silent scream of his unsolved puzzle.

In the following weeks, he confided in one more colleague, a psychiatrist friend, Dr. Alvin Freedman, who specialized in religious delusions and mania. Dr. Freedman listened patiently to Oliver's story, occasionally taking notes in a well-worn leather notebook.

“Oliver,” he said kindly, “I've known you a long time. You've never exhibited signs of mental illness. But this phenomenon you're describing… it's either a medical anomaly we can't detect or it's something beyond that.”

“Beyond that?” Oliver echoed.

Dr. Freedman shrugged. “I'm not religious, as you know, but we do see phenomena in psychiatry that have no easy explanation. Some patients exhibit psychosomatic stigmata from intense spiritual devotion, or from spiritual crises. But you're not devout. Could you be experiencing a psychosomatic reaction to some other trauma?”

“I don't think so,” Oliver said with frustration. “My life's stable. I'm not under unusual stress.”

Dr. Freedman offered a small, apologetic smile. “Then I'm afraid I can only point you back to the realm of the inexplicable.”

After that, Oliver retreated into silence. He realized no further scientific or medical test was likely to unravel this puzzle. The caretaker's words in the chapel returned to him again: If you're open to it, keep searching spiritually. As reluctant as he was to believe, he found no alternative. In his rational mind, he dreaded the idea of telling any priest, “I have the stigmata.” Yet the rational route was at a dead end.

CHAPTER 6. A Visit with the Friars

There was a Franciscan friary just across the bay, a small community of monks who administered a parish near Berkeley. Oliver discovered it during one of his late-night internet searches. Summoning his courage, he decided to visit them one Saturday morning. He had to walk carefully, using extra padding in his shoes, but the pain was tolerable.

The Franciscan friary stood on a gentle hillside. Clad in simple brown robes with white cords around their waists, the friars were a welcoming sight, greeting Oliver with curious warmth. One introduced himself as Brother Pietro, an older man with a kind face and gentle handshake.

“What brings you here, my friend?” Brother Pietro asked after Oliver explained he was not Catholic, nor was he planning to convert, but simply seeking answers.

Oliver glanced around, feeling conspicuous. “It's… complicated. Could I speak to you privately?”

Brother Pietro led him to a small side parlor with wooden chairs and a crucifix on the wall. Once seated, Oliver found himself trembling slightly.

“I—I've been experiencing something very strange,” Oliver began. “I don't quite know how to say this.” He took a breath. “I have wounds on my hands and feet, and no one can explain them. They're in the exact places where Christ was nailed to the cross. They won't heal. The doctors are baffled. And I— I'm terrified this might be the stigmata.”

Brother Pietro's eyes grew wide, and he crossed himself. “The stigmata. My goodness. May I see them?” Oliver unwrapped the bandages. The friar's breath caught. “They look real,” he whispered. “When did they appear?” Oliver recounted the story of his Good Friday visit to the Porziuncola chapel, noticing the image of Padre Pio, returning home, and finding the wounds. He shared how he'd sought every medical opinion he could, but no one had a clue.

Brother Pietro listened intently, then spoke softly. “St. Francis of Assisi was the first recorded stigmatist, as you likely know. It happened at Mt. Alverna. Two years before he died, he experienced a vision of the crucified seraph. Afterward, the wounds appeared. Padre Pio is another famous case. But both men were devout Catholics, wholly dedicated to the Passion of Christ. You are… not.”

Oliver nodded. “I respect the tradition, but I'm not a believer. That's why this makes no sense.”

Brother Pietro let out a gentle sigh. “God's ways often confound us. It's not for me to say if your wounds are truly from God. Usually, the Church investigates such claims thoroughly, often for years. But if this is from God, perhaps it is a call—an invitation. It might be a painful one, but it might also be a great grace.”

“Or,” Oliver interjected with a faint, bitter smile, “it's an undiscovered medical condition. Still, either way, I suppose I should keep looking for answers.”

The friar nodded. “It may be wise for you to learn more about St. Francis, or even visit Assisi yourself. Many pilgrims go there. They find clarity or transformation. And if your life has truly been touched by the stigmata of Christ, you may find new insight in the place where it first happened.”

Oliver, desperate, found the idea strangely compelling. “Go to Assisi?” “Yes,” Brother Pietro whispered. “Pray at the tomb of St. Francis. You might find you're not alone in this mystery.”

Oliver looked at his hands, the dull ache returning. “It's a long shot, but… I'll consider it.”

Before Oliver left, Brother Pietro prayed with him briefly, not insisting that Oliver had to believe but simply asking for God's guidance. Despite Oliver's skepticism, a quiet calm settled over him during that prayer, as though a space in his chest had momentarily opened to something new.

CHAPTER 7. Journey to Italy

After another sleepless week of wrestling with the idea, Oliver finally gave in to the strange, insistent pull to visit Assisi. Perhaps, he reasoned, it would at least bring some closure. He told his colleagues he needed a sabbatical for personal reasons—a partial truth—and arranged to travel alone.

He flew from San Francisco to Rome, arriving in a haze of jet lag. From Rome, he took a train to Assisi in the region of Umbria, watching the countryside roll by with farmland, medieval towns, and rolling green hills. Anxiety mingled with anticipation: he was chasing a religious legend to explain his own personal medical impossibility.

It was late afternoon when he arrived in Assisi, the pale stone buildings glowing gold under the sun. A taxi took him to a small guesthouse near the Basilica of St. Francis. He could see the grand structure perched on a hillside, its imposing lower basilica and the towering upper basilica above. Once he settled in, he decided to walk around the town a bit despite the discomfort in his bandaged feet.

Narrow cobblestone streets led past artisan shops, tiny restaurants, and an array of churches. The ambiance was hushed, reverent. Finally, he reached the Basilica of St. Francis itself. Tourists and pilgrims moved in quiet lines through the basilica, some descending to the crypt where St. Francis was entombed.

Oliver found the crypt. There, in the dimly lit chamber, a few people knelt in silent prayer. Oliver stood at the back, suddenly feeling overwhelmed. Here lay the mortal remains of a man who, eight centuries ago, had borne the stigmata Oliver now inexplicably shared.

He approached the tomb, bandaged hands clasped together. He wasn't sure how to “pray,” so he simply bowed his head and whispered, “I need help. If there is anything about this stigmata—if that's what it is—please help me understand.”

No thunder sounded, no voice from heaven. Oliver felt only the slow, steady beat of his own heart. But tears blurred his eyes. For a moment, he felt an inexplicable closeness to something—call it God, call it the memory of Francis, or call it the longing in Oliver's own soul. He left the crypt subdued, but unaltered physically. The wounds still throbbed.

The next morning, Oliver decided he would go to Mount Alverna—the place also known as La Verna, where Francis supposedly received the stigmata. This was the heart of the story. Perhaps he would find clarity or, at the very least, symbolic closure.

He rented a small car and navigated the winding roads. After a few hours, he arrived at the sanctuary of La Verna, perched high among verdant forests. The air was crisp, birdsong echoing through trees. A small group of pilgrims walked silently along the paths. The stone buildings of the sanctuary blended into the mountain itself.

Oliver made his way to the chapel built over the spot where Francis was said to have had his vision of the seraph. From the accounts he had read, Francis was deep in contemplative prayer, near the Feast of the Exaltation of the Cross, when he beheld an angelic figure bearing the marks of the crucified Christ, and upon the vision's departure, the saint discovered he bore the wounds.

Oliver stepped inside. The chapel was small, quiet except for the hush of the wind through the trees. He sat in a pew, removing the bandages from his hands. The wounds stared back at him, raw and unexplained. That's when he noticed someone else was there: a Franciscan friar kneeling near the altar. The friar turned, revealing a wizened face, kind yet searching eyes. He rose and approached Oliver with a slow, measured gait.

“Buongiorno,” the friar said softly. “You are not Italian, are you?”

Oliver shook his head. “No, I'm American. I came—” He hesitated. “Because of this.” He held up his palms. The friar's eyes widened but did not show shock; rather, there was a deep compassion.

“The stigmata,” the friar breathed. “How long have you had it?”

Oliver told him everything in hushed tones. The friar listened patiently, then introduced himself as Fra Gabriele. “I have lived here many years, meeting pilgrims who come in search of what St. Francis experienced. Many come seeking miracles. Yours is quite a story.”

“How can this be happening to me? I'm not religious,” Oliver said, voice quivering. “I'm a scientist. I've tried everything to explain it, but—”

Fra Gabriele laid a gentle hand on Oliver's shoulder. “Not all who receive these wounds are saints. Some are called to deeper understanding, to compassion, to a union with Christ's suffering. We do not know God's plans. But we do know that St. Francis himself never boasted of the stigmata—he actually tried to hide it. He saw it as both a gift and a heavy burden.”

Oliver's eyes filled with tears. “I've tried to hide it, too. It feels more like a curse than a blessing.”

Fra Gabriele offered a sad smile. “Perhaps it will be a blessing in time. For now, open your heart. When Francis was here, he prayed for the grace to feel Christ's love and suffering for the world. Perhaps you have been chosen to feel a small portion of that suffering—whether or not you realize it.”

Oliver closed his eyes. Something in Fra Gabriele's words resonated. He thought of the caretaker at the Porziuncola chapel in San Francisco, the hospital doctors, Brother Pietro's prayer, the crypt in Assisi. Each step had been drawing him closer to…something. But what?

CHAPTER 8. A Deeper Mystery

Over the next few days, Oliver spent hours at La Verna. He walked through the forest, sat in quiet chapels, and shared a few more conversations with Fra Gabriele. He also met pilgrims who came from various parts of the world—some Catholic, some not. They prayed, sang hymns, or simply sat in silence. Their sincerity moved Oliver in a way he couldn't put into words.

He delved into old Franciscan writings about the stigmata: how Francis had seen the seraph, how Brother Leo testified to the wounds, how later popes confirmed the authenticity. Oliver also read about controversies—skeptics then and now, calling it hysteria or fraud. Meanwhile, Oliver lived the phenomenon in his own flesh, each step a reminder of the piercing pains in his feet, each daily bandage change a reminder of the strange holes in his palms.

Despite all this, his wounds never worsened, never got infected. They simply remained.

One afternoon, Fra Gabriele called Oliver into a small library within the sanctuary, lined with musty old books and manuscripts. Some texts were centuries old, their pages yellowed, their script faded.

“I want to show you something,” Fra Gabriele said. He retrieved a battered volume and opened it to a passage describing Francis's final days. According to the text, Brother Elias, the Minister General, had written a letter after Francis's death, proclaiming the miraculous stigmata to the entire Order. It said: “I announce to you a great joy and a new miracle. … Our brother and father was seen to resemble the crucified Lord, bearing in his body the five wounds…”

Oliver read in silence. After a moment, he said, “I keep reading how those who bore these wounds found a profound sense of love, or union with God's suffering. I'm not sure I feel that.”

Fra Gabriele nodded gravely. “Miracles aren't always accompanied by immediate understanding. St. Francis spent much of his life in prayer even before he received the stigmata. Perhaps your journey is only beginning.”

That night, Oliver lay awake in his small guesthouse room, the wind rustling the trees outside. What if there's no scientific explanation? he thought. Am I to believe that some mystical force singled me out? It unsettled him deeply. He'd built his career on the premise that the human mind could be scientifically understood, that consciousness was a product of neural processes. Yet now, an experience so profoundly beyond the normal overshadowed all his assumptions.

CHAPTER 9. Science, Faith, and Quantum Questions

As days turned into weeks, Oliver extended his stay. His fascination with the stigmata's historical context intermingled with an emerging spiritual curiosity. To maintain his sense of identity, he corresponded frequently with his colleagues back at Stanford, updating them on the “condition.” They had no new leads.

In a moment of whimsy, Oliver even emailed an old friend who worked in quantum physics, half-jokingly asking if there was some entanglement between his body and centuries-old relics of Franciscan devotion. The friend replied with a half-serious remark: “Consciousness might shape reality. If your mind and some external field intersected, maybe you manifested the stigmata. That's about as plausible as anything else!” Oliver chuckled, appreciating that even among scientists, the line between imagination and possibility sometimes blurred.

But each day, the ache in his palms and feet reminded him that this was not an abstraction. He was living the intersection of matter and spirit. He felt strangely drawn to the quiet hush of chapels, to the gentle singing of monks during vespers, to the faint presence of something he could only call the Holy. Sometimes he found himself weeping during their chanting, unsure why.

CHAPTER 10. An Unexpected Encounter

One evening, as Oliver was walking the forested paths around La Verna, he noticed an elderly man in a simple black cloak, sitting on a stone bench, staring out at the sunset. Oliver approached, and the man turned, revealing a face that seemed both youthful and ancient, with dark eyes that seemed to look straight through Oliver.

“Are you seeking something, my friend?” the man asked, his voice surprisingly strong.

Oliver gave a small laugh. “I suppose I am. Maybe answers. Maybe peace.”

The man nodded knowingly. “St. Francis found his answers here, in surrender. Though I sense you have not come to surrender, but to investigate.”

Oliver felt slightly defensive. “I'm a scientist. I don't just accept experiences without understanding them.”

“Ah, yes,” the man said, “but to truly understand, one must accept. The mind and the heart must work together. That is the lesson of these woods, these stones. St. Francis didn't come to reason out God; he came to love.”

Oliver felt a wave of emotion. “I'm not sure I know how to do that.”

The man stood slowly. “Love is not about knowledge alone, but about participation. You bear the wounds of the One who is Love incarnate. That is invitation enough.”

Oliver blinked. “You know about—?”

The man simply nodded, eyes flicking to Oliver's bandaged palms. “Do not fear. The truth will be revealed in time, if you remain faithful to your questions.”

Before Oliver could say more, the man walked away down the path, disappearing into the thickening dusk. Oliver realized he'd never gotten the man's name or seen him before among the friars. An unsettling sense of wonder lingered as he headed back.

CHAPTER 11. A Strange Resolution

In the days that followed, Oliver felt a shift inside himself. The persistent tension he'd carried—the constant push to find a purely rational explanation—began to ease. He still wanted answers, but now he felt less frantic. He realized that part of him had begun to accept the possibility of a dimension beyond purely physical cause and effect.

Then, one morning, he awoke and found that the wounds on his feet were no longer oozing. Cautiously peeling back the bandages, he saw that fresh pink skin had started forming around the openings, though they were still visible. Surprised, he checked his palms and discovered the same new layer of healing tissue. They hadn't closed up entirely, but the constant bleeding had stopped. He flexed his fingers; the dull ache was still there, but somehow gentler.

He went to Fra Gabriele, who examined the wounds and smiled with relief. “They're starting to heal, Oliver. Perhaps that is a sign—of acceptance, of grace, of the next stage in your journey.”

Oliver felt a wave of gratitude and confusion. “But does that mean they'll just vanish, as if none of this ever happened?”

Fra Gabriele shrugged. “Only God knows. In the case of Padre Pio, his stigmata vanished the day he died, leaving no scars. In others, scars remain for life. Some remain open until death. It varies. Each soul's path is unique.”

Oliver swallowed hard. “If they do close up, I'll have no proof that any of this was real.”

Fra Gabriele's expression softened. “You have your memories, your changed heart. Sometimes that is the only proof we need.”

CHAPTER 12. Return to San Francisco

After nearly a month in Assisi and La Verna, Oliver felt the tug to return home. His sabbatical had stretched, and he needed to resume his responsibilities. More importantly, he sensed that any further progress would come through living out what he had learned, not secluding himself in pilgrimage sites.

He departed Italy in early summer, looking out over the Atlantic from the airplane window, still wrestling with a swirl of emotions. Though his wounds continued to slowly heal, they hadn't disappeared. Shallow scabs formed on each palm and sole, still forming distinct circles. He kept them covered with bandages, unsure how to explain them to colleagues and friends back home.

When he finally landed in San Francisco, he felt both relief and an odd sadness. Italy had become a crucible of transformation for him. Here, life moved at the frenetic pace he knew so well. He took a taxi back to his Nob Hill apartment, the driver weaving through the city's characteristic hills.

That first weekend, Oliver made a quiet trip to the Porziuncola chapel. He found the same caretaker, who recognized him with surprise.

“How are you?” the caretaker asked gently.

Oliver unwrapped his hands partially. “They've started to heal,” he said. “I went to Assisi and La Verna. I'm…coming to terms with it.”

A soft smile spread across the caretaker's face. “Welcome back. Sometimes, the spirit calls us away so we can return home renewed. I'm glad you've found some measure of peace.”

CHAPTER 13. A New Path

In the following months, Oliver gradually resumed his work at Stanford, teaching and directing research. His hands and feet finished scabbing over. Eventually, the scabs fell off, revealing four thin scars on his palms and feet, each shaped like a small elongated circle. The wounds never fully vanished; instead, they left these faint yet unmistakable marks—like pale reminders that refused to let him forget.

Oliver became almost protective of those scars. He wore them quietly, only occasionally revealing them to close friends or collaborators. He found he no longer needed to prove or disprove their origin. He was learning that the greatest mysteries often resist neat categorization. Life, he realized, was bigger than the boundaries he'd once drawn around it.

He also found himself oddly drawn to spiritual reading. He poured over texts about St. Francis, Teresa of Avila, John of the Cross, even Eastern mystics like Rumi. He dialogued with a Tibetan Buddhist monk who was visiting Stanford for a symposium on meditation and neuroscience. They discussed compassion, suffering, and the mind's capacity to bridge the spiritual and the physical. Oliver's perspective on consciousness began to expand. In teaching his neuroscience courses, he started acknowledging the intangible elements of human experience, aspects that might not be fully explained by scanning neural circuits.

His colleagues noticed the shift. Some teased him about becoming “the saintly scientist,” but Oliver would only smile. He had no illusions of sainthood, yet he felt more open-hearted, more empathic. He volunteered at local charities on weekends, especially in Chinatown, seeing how the simplest acts of kindness might be the greatest scientific test of all: Would the world change if more people lived compassionately? His personal transformation was real, the scars on his body quietly testifying to it.

CHAPTER 14. The Twist

A year passed. Oliver's life seemed to strike a new balance. He still couldn't define exactly what had happened that Good Friday. But he no longer needed to. The stigmata had forced him onto a path of spiritual exploration that changed his worldview entirely. He found new joy in small things, new humility in the face of the unknown.

Then, one summer afternoon, as Oliver was sitting in his office reviewing a draft research paper on “Neural Correlates of Religious Experience,” his phone buzzed. The voice on the other end was Dr. Miriam Nguyen, his immunologist friend who had done the biopsy months ago.

“Oliver, I've got some astonishing data,” she said, excitement brimming in her tone.

“What's going on?” he asked.

“Remember those skin samples I took from you last year? I put some of the leftover tissue in long-term storage. We just ran a set of advanced genetic tests on them—for an unrelated project about mutation rates in abnormal tissues. And the results are bizarre.”

“In what sense?” Oliver's heart pounded.

“Your samples show anomalies at the cellular level—something akin to accelerated tissue regeneration patterns, but not quite. It's as if the tissue has an unusual electrical potential or conduction property. It doesn't match anything in known medical literature. I can't begin to explain it.”

Oliver pressed the phone closer. “So you're saying there is something physically unique about the tissue from the wounds?”

“Exactly,” Miriam said. “I don't want to jump to wild conclusions, but it's possible there was some unknown biological mechanism at play. Could be an undiscovered phenomenon. I just wanted you to know we're investigating further, but it's so unconventional I'm not even sure where to publish.”

A swirl of emotion gripped Oliver. So there might be a scientific explanation after all—even if it's brand new territory. He thanked Miriam, feeling a strange mixture of validation and renewed confusion. On the one hand, this could be the earliest sign of a discovery that might be as monumental as CRISPR gene editing or new forms of immunotherapy. On the other hand, it only deepened the puzzle of how, and why, it had happened.

He sat back, gazing at his scarred palms. Maybe these marks—this stigmata—hold a secret that could merge science and faith in a way I never anticipated. For a moment, he felt both exhilaration and terror. What if everything—his mystical pilgrimage, his scars, his new outlook—was part of something bigger, not just spiritually, but scientifically?

Over the next few weeks, Oliver and Miriam began quietly exploring the anomalies, running small-scale tests on the tissue samples. The data indeed suggested an unconventional form of tissue conduction that defied standard biology, almost like an electrical synergy at the molecular level.

In parallel, Oliver continued attending a local Franciscan prayer group, finding solace in the gentle rhythms of faith. He told no one there about the new findings. He had a growing intuition that if a deeper explanation emerged—a bridging of science and mysticism—it might be best unveiled slowly, carefully, with humility.

CHAPTER 15. Final Revelation

Time marched on. Oliver led a kind of double life: eminent neuroscientist by day, quiet pilgrim by night, bridging science and devotion in ways that still unsettled him. Meanwhile, the faint scars remained, and occasionally they would ache on certain holy days—like Good Friday or on September 17th, the Feast of the Stigmata of St. Francis—though Oliver didn't speak of it often.

Then, one September 17th, near the anniversary of St. Francis's stigmata, Oliver found himself at a small candlelit service in the National Shrine of St. Francis in San Francisco. A handful of Franciscan friars were gathered with parishioners, reading from the accounts of Brother Elias and St. Bonaventure about Francis's vision on Mt. Alverna. Oliver stood at the back, listening quietly. Candlelight flickered over the wooden pews.

Suddenly, a gentle warmth spread across his palms and feet. It wasn't painful—more like an embrace of heat. He looked down at his hands. The scars seemed to glow faintly in the candlelight, though it might have been his imagination. The readings finished, and the small congregation prayed:

“Lord Jesus Christ, who reproduced in the flesh of the most blessed Francis, the sacred marks of your own sufferings… enable us by his merits and prayers to bear the cross without faltering and to bring forth worthy fruits of penitence.”

Oliver felt tears slip down his cheeks. Bear the cross without faltering. The prayer resonated with his journey, all the anguish and joy of the past year. He realized with clarity: he was living those words. He had been forced to carry a cross of disbelief, confusion, and transformation. And in the end, it had brought forth a more compassionate, open-hearted man.

In that moment, he no longer required a final resolution about how or why the stigmata first appeared. Whether it was a purely divine miracle, a psychosomatic phenomenon unleashed by some quantum-level entanglement, or a gene expression anomaly—none of it fully explained the transformation of his soul. The stigmata had done its work.

When the service ended, Oliver stepped outside into the San Francisco night. The caretaker from the chapel, who had first spoken to him back on Good Friday, approached, smiling gently. “You look peaceful,” he observed.

Oliver nodded. “I think I finally am,” he said. “I still don't know how to explain these scars, or what exactly happened to me. But I've realized… maybe the explanation isn't the point.”

The caretaker nodded in understanding. “The point is love—and the willingness to let that love transform us. Faith, science, or both—only you can decide which path to follow. Maybe it's both.”

Oliver clasped his hands together, the old ache replaced by a calm warmth. “Yes,” he whispered. “I think it's both.”

He gave a final look at the chapel, at the old painting of Padre Pio. He thought of the caretaker's quiet faith, of Fra Gabriele's patient counsel, of Brother Pietro's invitation, and of St. Francis's unwavering humility. And he thought of the still-lingering mystery in his own tissues that might open a door to breakthroughs in medical science. All these threads wove together inside him like a tapestry. This is my life now, he realized—a life where the unknown is both an invitation and a revelation.

As he walked away into the lights of Chinatown, the evening bustle carrying exotic spices and the chatter of neighbors, Oliver felt an unshakable conviction: the greatest mysteries cannot be contained, explained, or dismissed. They must be lived, allowing them to shape us from within. Even now, with bandaged feet and scarred palms, Oliver understood—he would forever carry, in body and soul, the marks of a mystery that transcended easy comprehension.

And that, he thought, was the truest revelation of all.

EPILOGUE:.THE TWIST UNFOLDS

Several years later, Oliver and Dr. Miriam Nguyen's research on his anomalous skin tissue reached a tipping point. They quietly published a technical paper with a cautious title—Preliminary Observations of Atypical Tissue Regeneration and Conductivity in Human Dermal Samples—in a respected scientific journal. It generated mild curiosity at first. But as a new wave of researchers delved into the underlying data, it became clear that these findings might revolutionize how scientists understood the relationship between consciousness, biology, and the possibility of mind-body interactions.

Still, the paper omitted any mention of the context of those tissue samples or the possibility that they were linked to the stigmata. Oliver chose to remain silent about that part. If the world was ready, perhaps it would eventually discover the deeper story. For now, it was enough that the stigmata had quietly left their imprint on him—and possibly on the future of scientific exploration.

Late one night, Oliver gazed at the stars outside his window, reflecting on the wondrous, unexpected path he had traveled since stumbling into the Porziuncola chapel on a random Good Friday. He touched the thin scars on his palms, feeling neither fear nor confusion. Instead, he felt hope—hope that one day, humankind would learn to honor both the spiritual and the scientific, bridging heaven and earth within the human heart. That, he realized with a grateful smile, was the lasting mark of The Stigmata in Chinatown.