INTEGRAL WORLD MAILING LIST
 
http://www.integralworld.net
Newsletter Nr. 1.411
Amsterdam, September 13, 2025

The Two Faces of Integral Theory - How Ken Wilber's Framework Succeeds as a Meta-Map but Struggles as a Theory of Everything - Frank Visser / ChatGPT

Ken Wilber's Integral Theory (IT) has been one of the most ambitious intellectual projects of the past half-century. It aspires to weave together the findings of science, psychology, philosophy, and spirituality into a single coherent framework. Its centerpiece, AQAL (“all quadrants, all levels, all lines, all states, all types”), promises to be a map of reality comprehensive enough to account for everything from particle physics to mystical experience.

Yet, from the beginning, critics have raised concerns that Integral Theory is less an integration of existing knowledge and more a metaphysical superstructure imposed upon it. Supporters, meanwhile, argue that Wilber has been misunderstood—that IT is not a scientific hypothesis but a meta-framework for orienting oneself amid the complexity of knowledge. The tension between these two readings lies at the heart of IT's ongoing debate.

This essay presents the strongest critique of Integral Theory, the strongest counter-critique offered by its defenders, and a neutral assessment of how persuasive those counter-arguments really are.

Read more:
https://www.integralworld.net/visser587.html